Comment du Jour

April Showers bring May Flowers!! 

Comment du Jour

French Elections in New York City/Round One

French citizens voting in Carroll Gardens Brooklyn.


French around the world voted in their homeland's hotly contested national elections. 
In the first round of voting more than ten candidates from the political mainstream 
to the nut fringe were ballot choices.  

In the New York area there were 9 polling places to cast the ballots.

As in France itself, center Left candidate Emmanuel Macron came in first;
here in New York local voters gave him 52 percent of the total.
Conservative candidate Francois Fillon came in second in America with 
29 percent but failed to place in France for the upcoming second  round.

Marine Le Pen the nationalist firebrand placed second in France but 
barely scored in the USA garnering a mere 3 percent of the vote.  

This is the first time in the history of the French Fifth Republic in that candidates from the major parties are not represented in the Second Round of voting.

Macron faces off against Le Pen in the runoff on 7 May.   

Comment du Jour

Sultan Erdogan’s Uneasy Turkish Turban

There’s troubling news from across the Bosphorus, the narrow slip of water separating Europe from Asia-minor.  In a decisive but dividing referendum, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan narrowly gained the political blessing he sought by winning 51 percent of the nationwide vote.  Erdogan’s divisive victory (51/49 percent), allows the increasingly authoritarian Turkish ruler to gain sweeping powers to change the constitution and to allow him near unrivaled power until 2029.  

Turkey remains a key piece on the geopolitical board linking Europe to the Mid East and the Mediterranean to the Black Sea.  But its strategic situation has been sadly compromised by its border with Syria whose civil war continues to spill over into Turkish territory both in terms of violent terrorism and humanitarian hosting of nearly three million refugees.  

Contrary to many assumptions, Turkey’s economy in recent years was strong and growth- oriented.  Turkish tourism was booming and deservedly so.   The Syrian crisis changed the equation dramatically.  Tourism has taken a dive downwards. 

The once staunchly secular Turkish Republic of Kemal Ataturk was founded in 1923.  The new 18  article constitutional changes focus on granting of executive powers to an elected President and the abolition of the Prime Minister.  Equally Cabinet Ministers can be chosen from outside the Parliament.  The ruling Justice and Development party (AKP) has changed the rules of the game. Erdogan became Prime Minister in 2002 and was elected President in 2014. 

So who backed Erdogan in this controversial vote?  While the ruling AK pressed for a Yes vote,

the “No” vote prevailed in Istanbul and Ankara the capital.  In coastal Izmir, a secular stronghold No gained 69 percent.  Equally the restive ethnic Kurdish regions voted No.  

Yet in the vast Islamic religious Anatolian interior and the Black Sea, Erdogan’s support was rock solid.  A commentator dubbed it “Anatolia versus the Metropolis.”   

Tragically Turks apparently voted to elect a dictator. 

Crucial to the campaign was Erdogan’s lobbying the 5 million plus Turkish vote overseas, mostly in Europe and especially in Germany and the Netherlands.  Tensions were high as Erdogan’s minions shamelessly campaigned in Europe; in the Netherlands the Yes reached 71 percent, France 64 percent and in Germany 63 percent.  

The Turkish vote in the USA on the other hand, was resoundingly against Erdogan with 83 percent voting NO!

During the heated campaign President Erdogan’s gloating rhetorical rants against European democracies as “crusaders” and “Nazis and fascists” reminded Euro-skeptics of their initial reservations about Turkey’s fitness to join the European Union.  Erdogan’s unalloyed authoritarianism is often masked through using Islam as a legitimizing force to rule.

Hurryiet Daily News columnist Semih Idiz opined, “Turkey’s parliamentary system of 94 years has been replaced with a presidential one that is not restricted by any checks and balances. This can’t be reversed…  This hardly augers a good start for a Turkey visibly divided along active social, religious and ethnic fault lines.”

Sultan Erdogan has been emboldened but remains nervous over his slim mandate. So did Turks choose to elect a dictatorship?   Turkey’s populism has been unleashed but its outcomes are decidedly unpredictable.  Despondingly, Turkey’s once staunchly secular state has morphed into an increasingly authoritarian Islamic system which has apparently chosen to look more like the Middle East than Europe.