Wednesday, October 14, 2020

Comment du Jour

 




German Reunification’s Peaceful Lesson



Germany’s reunification is now history.  It seemed not so long ago that the Berlin Wall had fallen in 1989, Central European countries had regained their sovereignty through the freedom tsunami sweeping Europe, and unimaginably on 3 October 1990, West and East Germany, the front line frontier of a very Cold War had reunified in peace and freedom.  


Almost as in a fairytale the two separate states, the Federal Republic of Germany

(West) and the communist German Democratic Republic (East), had almost magically merged into one nation without violence, with the legal blessing of the WWII Allied powers, and through the political foresight of German Chancellor Helmut Kohl.   


Perhaps the most enduring image of divided Germany stood as the Berlin Wall, built in 1961.


The Wall separated free West Berlin controlled by the Americans, British and French from Soviet controlled East Berlin.  The Wall provided a vivid juxtaposition of a divided land; it was designed to keep people inside the worker’s paradise and stop others from trying to flee. 


Indeed between 1949 and 1961 over 2.7 million people fled East Germany for the West.  In Berlin itself over 171 were killed at the Wall while escaping. 


I first visited the divided German capital in the late 1970’s; the once grand cosmopolitan city  remained a stunning tableaux in black and white. While the Wall brutally separated families and neighbors, it equally illuminated the vivid contrast between prosperous West Berlin and the grey, dreary and shoddy East Berlin.  


Though the same people, West and East Germany had fundamentally different state personalities; the Federal Republic was aligned with the West, politically free and with a prosperous turbo-charged market economy.  East Germany was the poor cousin steeped in socialism, and part of the Soviet sphere.  


Complicated economic and social comparisons aside, there’s a novel way to understand the contrast between West and East Germany; their celebrated automobiles.  West Germany was known for its iconic Mercedes-Benz cars and trucks.  East Germany sported the Trabant, a small fiberglass 25 horsepower auto which chugged along belching a blue-grey smoke. Citizens in  West Germany’s consumer society had access to the Mercedes line and it was not uncommon to own one.  In the East there was a multi-year waiting list to buy a treasured Trabi—which came in the dazzling colors of white, penicillin green and black.  Enough said!

 

In June 1987, President Ronald Reagan, while visiting Berlin and speaking at the Brandenburg Gate demanded, “Mr. Gorbachev Tear down this Wall.”  Reagan’s comments touched off a     cascade of shock, criticism, and condescension and from a political class who viewed the      president’s call as an incendiary challenge to an accepted status quo; the Wall. Elites cringed.


But then came the unexpected Freedom Tsunami of Autumn 1989 when Central Europe changed. 


By 1990, the geopolitical stars were aligned perfectly as the four Allied powers, the victors over Naziism in WWII,  acted as cautious midwives to the creation of a reunited Germany.  


Though economically costly, Kohl’s political choice for unity was the right one.  But despite the progress, there’s still political angst among the 17 million Easterners; some speak of a psychological divide between East and West Germany.



Emily Haber, Germany’s  Ambassador to the United States stresses, “The trust and friendship of our neighbors and allies, first and foremost the U.S., helped bring about this unique success    story.  We will never forget America’s support. Thirty years later, we celebrate that historic day and say, ‘Danke!’ to the American people.”


Reunification’s success was anchored in close and enduring Transatlantic ties; let’s refocus on renewing those vital links of friendship.

 


Friday, October 2, 2020

Comment du Jour

 



COVID Crisis Clouds United Nations Assembly




Since March the world has been battered by the Covid-19 virus.  Nearly a million people have died and many more been sickened by this “invisible enemy.”  From its origins in China, through its spread into Europe, the United States and Latin America, the virus has ravished societies and rocked the social bedrock of countries round the world.


The annual UN General Assembly, celebrating its 75th anniversary,  has been forced to meet virtually, with online video sessions replacing the diplomatic pomp and pageantry of years past.  


“In a world turned upside down, this General Assembly Hall is among the strangest sights of all,” lamented UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres.  



Here are a few of the more interesting speeches.


Britain’s bombastic Prime Minister Boris Johnson to liven up what’s largely been a droning video debate;  “Never in the history of our species, not since the almighty felled the tower of babel,  has the human race been so obsessed with one single topic of conversation…  COVID-19, coronavirus, has united humanity as never before.”


Boris Johnson then warned, the crisis has also been an extraordinary force for division. We have all been up against the same enemy. The same tiny opponent threatening everyone in much the same way, but members of the UN have still waged 193 separate campaigns, as if every country somehow contains a different species of human being.”


He counseled, “After nine months of fighting COVID-19, the very notion of the international community looks, frankly, pretty tattered. And we know that we simply can’t continue in this way.” That is Unless we get our act together. Unless we unite and turn our fire against our   common foe, we know that everyone will lose.”  


Boris Johnson pledged the United Kingdom’s massive additional funding for the controversial World Health Organization as well as to global vaccine research and distribution efforts. 


Interestingly earlier in the year Prime Minister Johnson was himself hospitalized for having   contracted the Corona virus.  Moreover even today the UK has a proportionally higher Corona virus fatality rate than the United States.



India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi offered some controversy; “Over the last 8 to 9 months, the whole world has been battling the pandemic of the Coronavirus. Where is the United Nations in this joint  fight against the pandemic? Where is its effective response?”


He added “Reform in the responses, in the processes, and in the very character of the United Nations is the need of the hour.”


Prime Minister Modi then recited a long litany of India’s historic contributions to the UN, but then asked rhetorically why India has not been awarded a permanent seat on the powerful fifteen  member Security Council?  


He said,  “the international community today is faced with a very important question: Whether the character of the institution, constituted in the prevailing circumstances of 1945, is relevant even today?”


India has been devastated by the virus; with almost six million cases, nearly 100,000 people have died.   



Charles Michel of the European Union (EU) made an interesting observation “I have often been asked a question:  In the new rivalry between the United States and China, which side is the European Union on?”


He stated, “My answer is the following...We are deeply connected with the United States. We share ideals, values and a mutual affection that have been strengthened through the trials of history. They remain embodied today in a vital transatlantic alliance.” 


Michel added, “We do not share the values on which the political and economic system in China is based. And we will not stop promoting respect for universal human rights. Including those of minorities such as the Uighurs or in Hong Kong.”



Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis was one of the few leaders to courageously criticize the WHO; “Unfortunately, and I say it with regret, the response we have seen by the World Health Organization has failed to exercise global health leadership. It did not act resolutely after the pandemic outbreak in Wuhan, China, and had a very limited success – to put it softly – in helping countries prevent, protect against, and respond to disease events.” 

 

Contrary to past Assembly sessions speakers did not cite the political laundry list of world crises; Korea was barely mentioned,  there were ritualistic mentions of  the Two State solution for Israel and Palestine, and few countries such as the USA, cited human rights in Cuba and Venezuela.    


The Covid crisis has clouded the enthusiasm from this year’s anniversary General Assembly.  


But it’s oft darkest before the dawn.